When it comes to maintaining a home that has stood the test of time, few challenges are as daunting as addressing an aging tile roof. You may find yourself at a crossroads, contemplating whether to opt for the Lift and Relay method or to invest in a brand-new tile roof. At San Diego County Roofing & Solar, we understand the gravity of this decision and aim to provide you with the most reliable information to make an informed choice.

Lift and Relay Method: A Closer Look

The Lift and Relay method involves removing the existing tiles, installing new dual-layer flashing, and replacing the underlayment with two layers for enhanced durability. Weather blocks are added to the ridges and hips, and the existing tiles are reinstalled. Any broken tiles discovered during the process are replaced. This approach generally comes with a workmanship warranty ranging from five to ten years. However, there is no guarantee on the re-used tiles.

Cost Implications

The average cost for a Lift and Relay job for a roof area of 2,500 square feet is around $10,000. This includes the cost of new flashing, underlayment, and labor.

Brand New Tile Method: The Premium Choice

With the Brand New Tile Method, the existing tiles are completely removed and disposed of. New dual-layer flashing and underlayment are installed, along with weather blocks on the ridges and hips. New tiles are then laid across the entire structure. This method comes with a 15-year workmanship warranty and a staggering 50-year warranty on the tile.

Cost Considerations

The average cost for a new tile roof, using the Brand New Tile Method, for the same 2,500 square-foot area is approximately $12,500. This includes both labor and material costs.

Making the Right Choice: Value Over Cost

When you consider the long-term implications, especially if you plan to sell your property in the future, the Brand New Tile Method offers undeniable advantages. A new tile roof not only passes rigorous inspections but also adds significant value to your property. On the other hand, a Lift and Relay roof may show signs of aging and mismatched tiles, which could be a red flag for potential buyers.

Why Choose San Diego County Roofing & Solar?

As one of the leading roofing contractors in San Diego, we offer both methods to cater to different needs and budgets. Our primary goal is to provide you with the best available solution tailored to your specific circumstances. Your satisfaction is our ultimate aim.


The decision between Lift and Relay and a new tile installation is a significant one, affecting not just the immediate state of your home but its long-term value as well. At San Diego County Roofing & Solar, we are committed to helping you make the most informed decision. Whether you’re looking for local roofing companies in San Diego or seeking expert advice, we are here to guide you every step of the way.

By understanding the pros and cons of each method, you can make a choice that aligns with both your immediate needs and long-term goals. Choose wisely, and your roof will serve you well for years to come.